Bookmark ReproAlert!
Tell a Friend about ReproAlert!
Add a Link to ReproAlert.com!
Repro Alert - Your Guide to Fake & Reproduction Antiques & Collectibles
Fake & Repro Radio & TV Premiums

A visual guide to identifying
fake, fantasy, & reproduction
"vintage" collectors items on
eBay, Yahoo & other venues

Many premiums were offered from Captain Midnight, Lone Ranger, Dick Tracy, Radio Orphan Annie & other radio shows of the era, along with the giveaways from the early television years. But many of the present day collectors that weren't around at the time are often fooled by today's cheap imitations. Here are a few that we're aware of. If you know of others & have pics, let's see 'em! Email me at .
Repro version shown. Authentic on mouseover.
Buck Jones Club Badge
Buck Jones Club
Horseshoe Badge
Repro (shown) is cast metal with an oval attachment.
Authentic (on mouseover): The original Buck Jones Club Horseshoe badge was stamped brass. It was offered by Grape Nut Flakes in 1937 from the radio series Hoofbeats. 1-piece pin is soldered to back.
Kelloggs Buck Rogers Origin Storybook
Buck Rogers
Origin Storybook
Repro (shown): Full color reprint from 1994- available from Amazon for $6.95. Nicely done. No Kellogg's ad on back.
Authentic (on mouseover): This Buck Rogers Origin Storybook was a Kellogg's premium from 1933. Original has Kellogg's ad on back cover.
1941 Captain Midnight Code-O-Graph
Captain Midnight
1941 Code-O-Graph
Repro (shown): Cast metal. Rotor attached with hole through center.
Authentic (on mouseover): Original 1941 Captain Midnight Code-O-Graph is stamped brass. Rotor held in place by the tabs on each side. 1st of 9 Captain Midnight Code-O-Graphs from Ovaltine.
Captain Midnight '41 COG
Rear View
Repro (shown): Back is very plain with no way to set the master code. Replica mfg. by Klutz, Inc.
Authentic (on mouseover): On the rotor are 2 settings for "Master Code" & "Super Code". (Thanks to Stephen Kallis, Jr. for the info & pics)
1941 Captain Midnight Code-O-Graph
Captain Midnight
1941 Code-O-Graph (2)
Repro (shown): A much nicer looking replica than the previous from Klutz. Cast metal. Note hole in center of rotor.
Authentic (on mouseover): Original 1941 Captain Midnight Code-O-Graph is stamped brass. Rotor held in place by the tabs on each side
Captain Midnight '41 COG (2) Rear View
Repro (shown): Cast metal. Note the pin is much lower.
Authentic (on mouseover): Thanks again to Stephen Kallis Jr. for the info & pics on both replica versions plus the authentic.
Dick Tracy Girls Division Badge
Dick Tracy
Girls Division
Repro (shown): Oval shaped pin attachment on back w/ point protected. Shadows on face of pin artificial darkened.
Authentic (on mouseover): Dick Tracy premium from 1939 from Quaker cereals. Stamped brass. Safety pin type soldered directly to back of badge w/ no oval attachment.
Dick Tracy Secret Service Patrol Pinback
Dick Tracy
Secret Service Patrol
Repro (shown): 3" cello. May also be in other sizes.
Authentic (on mouseover): This 1938 Dick Tracy Members pinback is seen mainly as a 1 3/8" litho, but there is also an authentic 1 1/4" cello version w/ a few minor design differences- both from Parisian Novelty.
Fake Dick Tracy Crime Stoppers Badge
Dick Tracy
Crime Stoppers
Repro (shown): Cast metal w/ oval shaped pin attachment.
Authentic (on mouseover): Original Dick Tracy Crime Stoppers badge of the 50s is stamped brass w/ simple, 1-piece pin soldered directly to back of badge.
Dick Tracy Member
Secret Service Patrol
Repro (shown): Stamped metal. Marked on back: "A.E. CO. UTICA N.Y.". Oval shaped pin attachment on back w/ point protected.
Authentic: 1939 Dick Tracy premium from Quaker cereals. Original was stamped brass. Pin attached directly to back.
Don Winslow Squadron of Peace Ensign
Repro (shown): Cast w/ oval shaped pin attachment on back. Shadows on face of pin artificial darkened.
Authentic (on mouseover): Simple, 1-piece pin soldered directly to back.
Note: Both say "ROBBINS CO. ATTLEBORO" on back.
Green Hornet Adventure Club Pinback
Green Hornet
Adventure Club
Repro (shown): 1 1/4" cello. Note extra leg at front tip of left wing.
Authentic (on mouseover): No extra leg. Also inside of wings is a fine dot pattern. "PHILADELPHIA BADGE CO. PHILA PA" on curl
Green Hornet Strikes Again
Adventure Club
Repro (shown): 1 1/4" cello. Main lettering style is typeset (Futura).
Authentic: 1 1/4" cello. Only 2 colors- dark green & tan (no red, blue,or yellow). Main lettering was not typeset (hand lettered).
Green Hornet Loyalty Club Pinback
Green Hornet
Loyalty Club
Repro (shown): 1 1/4" cello.
Authentic (on mouseover): 1 1/4" cello. The authentic Green Hornet Loyalty Club pinback is quite scarce. It's very easy to spot the difference between the two. The real one has only 2 shades of green (no red, blue,or yellow).
Fantasy Howdy Doody TV Pin
Howdy Doody
Television Set
Fantasy Item: 1 1/8" x 7/8".
Also seen: Lone Ranger, Roy Rogers, Roy Rogers on Trigger, Annie Oakley on Target (in color), Superman (George Reeves), Amos & Andy w/ Kingfish, Three Stooges, Elvis, Beatles, KISS, Cisco Kid & Pancho...
Jet Jackson Ring
Jet Jackson
Ring
Fantasy Item. After Ovaltine had given up sponsorship of Captain Midnight in the late 50s, the show continued in some areas under the name Jet Jackson. There are no known authentic Jet Jackson premiums.
Jimmie Allen Flying Cadet Airplane Pin
Jimmie Allen Flying Cadet
Airplane Pin
Repro (shown): Cast metal. Artificial shading around lettering. Note the uneven wing lengths. Pin point protected with an extra bend.
Authentic (on mouseover): Stamped brass. Point on pin is exposed.
Lone Ranger Bond Bread Safety Club
Lone Ranger Safety Club
Bond Bread
Repro (shown): Cast metal. Oval shaped pin attachment on back w/ point protected.
Authentic (on mouseover): Stamped brass appx. 1 1/4" x 1 1/2". Simple, 1-piece pin, w/ point exposed, soldered directly to back of badge.
Lone Ranger Safety 
	  Scout Badge
Lone Ranger Safety Scout
Silvercup Bread
Repro (shown): Oval shaped pin attachment on back w/ point protected. Image looks flat.
Authentic (on mouseover): Simple 1-piece pin w/ point exposed soldered directly to back of badge. Lone Ranger & Silver are more dimensional.
Lone Ranger Chief Scout Badge
Lone Ranger
Chief Scout Badge
Repro (shown): Brown tone. "SILVERCUP" in thin sans-serif lettering. Oval shaped pin attachment.
Authentic (on mouseover): Bright plated brass. "SILVERCUP" in bold serifed letters. Pin soldered directly to back.
Fake Lone Ranger Club Badge
Lone Ranger Club
Horseshoe Badge
Repro (shown): Cast metal w/ oval shaped pin attachment.
Authentic: Stamped brass w/ simple, 1-piece pin soldered directly to back of badge.
Radio Orphan Annie Secret Society Pin
Radio Orphan Annie's
Secret Society
Repro (shown): Has an extra bend on the pin on back to protect from the point.
Authentic (on mouseover): Stamped brass. No extra bend on pin (point exposed).
Rocky Jones Space Ranger Pinback
Rocky Jones
Silvercup Bread PB
Repro (shown): Cello
Authentic (on mouseover):
1 3/8" litho. Johnston Cookies example shown
Roy Rogers Deputy Sheriff Badge
Roy Rogers
Deputy Sheriff
Repro (shown): Cast metal. Plain back.
Authentic (on mouseover): Original Roy Rogers Deputy Sheriff Badge was a 1950 Quaker Cereal premium. Back has red plastic whistle w/ secret compartment. Stamped brass with high detail.
Fake Supermen of America Patch
Supermen of America
Cloth Patch
Repro (shown): 3.75" full color embroidered patch.
Authentic: Original is a rare 1940 Superman comic premium from Action Comics. I don't believe the original is this large, nor embroidered.
Signal Oil Tarzan Club Pinback
Tarzan Club
Signal Oil PB
Repro (shown): 2 1/4" cello.
Authentic (on mouseover): 1" cello.
Tarzan Radio Club Pin
Tarzan Radio Club
Repro (shown): 1" Cloisonné. Oval shaped pin attachment on back. Inner circle is unbroken.
Authentic (on mouseover):
1 1/2" stamped brass w/ simple 1-piece pin soldered to back. Foot goes over the inner circle & touches text below. Bottom line bolder.